Talking out of turn

I saw a news report on a local TV station over the weekend about L.A. school bus drivers caught using their cell phones while transporting students. The report had a "gotcha" quality to it, with the reporter confronting the drivers as they got off the bus. This wasn't the worst piece of TV journalism that I've seen, but it did make a point -- bus drivers are violating California law by using cell phones while driving a school bus.

Exceptions to this law, enacted in 2005, allow for the use of cell phones in an emergency and for work-related calls. We should give these drivers the benefit of the doubt and assume they were using their phones for work purposes. But, human nature being what it is, I'm guessing that other bus drivers are using their cell phones illegally.

Which is a problem. Not only is it against the law in California (and several other states), it's also extremely dangerous. The National Transportation Safety Board issued a report on a crash that was apparently caused by a motorcoach driver who crashed into a bridge overpass because he was distracted by a hands-free, cell-phone conversation. Several students were injured, one seriously.

So much of the focus of TV news is negative these days that it's often dispiriting to watch regularly. But I think we've got to do a better job of policing ourselves and reducing the chances that a TV camera is capturing videotape of prohibited activities. Then we won't have the gotcha moment that so many so-called journalists confuse with real reporting.

I'll get off my soapbox now.

Keep it safe.

Steve

 

Print | posted on Monday, May 21, 2007 5:20 PM

Comments

 re: Talking out of turn

left by Michele at 5/21/2007 8:34 PM
It is sad too when incidents are reported to management where drivers see other drivers taking actions that are dangerous, stupid or just plain illegal and it is just brushed off as "tattling".

They could do all of us a great service by vigilance in policing their own drivers before the video cameras show up.

 re: Talking out of turn

left by Geoff Bridgman at 5/26/2007 11:11 AM
The policy at our school district is that all cell phones should not only be turned off while operating the school bus, but stored out of sight. While the policy is not strictly enforced, to the best of my knowledge, few, if any, of our drivers abuse their cell phones. They are used while the bus is in operation if it's of vital importance to contact home base. Private conversations take place only when the bus is out of service and stopped. Cell phones can serve as an important communications tool in the case of emergencies and I think it's unrealistic to expect drivers to have them totally disabled while driving.

Geoff Bridgman
Pocono Mountain School District
Swiftwater, PA

 re: Talking out of turn

left by Dave Wilson at 7/18/2007 7:42 AM
As a Head Start program, we are mandated to have a communications system. With a 5 county range and communication between bus and parents necessary we have found cell phones to be the best way to accomplish this. We are also mandated to have a monitor on the bus at all times. We have the monitor answer the cell phones whenever possible so as not to distract the driver.

Dave Wilson
Transportation/Maintenance Manager
Three Affiliated Tribes Head Start

Add A Comment

Title   
Name 
Email (never displayed) 
Url 
Comments   
Please add 8 and 6 and type the answer here: