The school bus and the bridge

I'm still trying to wrap my mind around the bridge collapse in Minneapolis. It's now considered the worst disaster in Minnesota history, and the horrifying images certainly will endure in my memory for years to come.

As you might expect, a lot of attention was placed on the school bus that was on the bridge during the collapse. I don't know if it qualifies as a miracle that none of the passengers was killed, but it's pretty close. The vehicle, which was carrying 62 people, is estimated to have dropped 30 or 40 feet as the bridge buckled underneath it. Credit has to be given to the sturdiness of the bus for helping to minimize the injuries to the passengers and driver.

But credit must also go to the people who assisted in evacuating the more than 50 children on the bus, which was headed back from a swimming trip organized by a social services group. Those heroes included staff members of the social services group, as well as passers-by, who helped to evacuate the children through the emergency exit and lead them to safety off the bridge.

One of the heroes was Gary Babineau, whose pick-up truck was on the bridge when it collapsed. He said he was leaving the scene when he heard screams and crying coming from the school bus. He immediately ran over to assist, helping to move children from the bridge to the road below. "Anyone would have done the same thing," he modestly told a Minneapolis radio station.

Babineau also told the radio station that the children who were evacuated from the bus were so confused and terrified that they wanted to get off the bridge immediately, even though it was safer to walk farther down the bridge, where the elevation was 7 or 8 feet instead of 15. "They were so shaken up that they weren't listening," he said. Had they fallen off the bridge at the higher elevation, they could have been injured more during the rescue than in the bridge collapse itself.

Key to this discussion, then, is the importance of knowing how to evacuate children from a bus in an emergency, and the importance of keeping them under control once they've been evacuated. No one on the school bus could ever have expected that the bridge would collapse, but the same rules for emergency evacuations apply. More attention to the importance of emergency evacuation drills is in order.

Until next time.

Steve 

 

Print | posted on Tuesday, August 07, 2007 2:55 PM

Comments

# re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Ted Finlayson-Schueler at 8/7/2007 4:35 PM
"I kicked the coolers out of the way." For those of us whe lived through Carrolton, those words of the school bus driver were a chilling reminder of what we have forgotten about bus fires. Baggage inside the passenger compartment is and unacceptable impediment to evacuation in light of what we know. Luckily, this time it didn't have an impact but will it take another Carrolton for us to remember this safety lesson?

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Norman Mars at 8/7/2007 4:36 PM
Thank God that the bus was sturdy and remained intact, that there were no serious injuries to the passengers, their chaperones, or the driver, and that there were responsible adults nearby who were willing to step up and do the right thing by helping to get those children off that bridge and to a place of safety. This can be a lesson to those who would say that repeated safety evacuation drills are unnecessary and a waste of time and money. We all hope that what is learned during a safety evacuation drill is never needed, but it is much better to know what to do in an emergency and never need to use it than to be faced with an emergency and not know what to do.

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Brendan Anderson at 8/7/2007 4:39 PM
Well as a school bus driver living in Minnesota watching that on TV, knowing that all children were removed alive and about 10 of them injured. One though comes to mind...What if that bus landed in the river and all 62 passengers had seatbelts on? How many would have survived? How many would have survived if it landed in the river and there were no seatbelts? We will thankfully never know, but the seatbelt issue would have come into play if it had happened.

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Linda Sallaz at 8/7/2007 4:47 PM

This also emphasizes the importance of keeping the aisle and the emergency door clear. This should be shown to every coach or sponsor in the country.Being a Christian I also must give thanks to God for having HIs hand on that bus and driver.

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Geoff Bridgman at 8/7/2007 4:49 PM
The bridge collapse in Minneapolis, MN is an excellent example of the old adage: "Expect the unexpected!" This certainly applies to school bus driving. You need to be on your toes all the time. Never relax too much. A bridge collapse is certainly an extreme example of the unexpected, but it points out how easily and quickly ANYTHING can happen. We drill our students on emergency evacuations twice a year. The kids are cooperative and have the routine down pat. It's impossible to predict how anyone would react to a situation such as that of the bridge collapse. All anyone can do is be as prepared as you possibly can be for any situation that might arise.

Geoff Bridgman, Driver
Pocono Mountain School District West
Mt. Pocono, PA

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Kathy Weidman at 8/8/2007 3:59 AM
I too, watched the scene of the collapse in disbelief and awe, but at one point, a local (to MN) person being interviewed (I thought he was a politician) stated that "the children riding in the school bus were protected by the seat belts in the bus". I was surprised, and doubted his knowledge...What are the facts? Did this bus, which was marked "CHARTER", have seats belts? Was this person being sarcastic? Or was he just misinformed? He went on about the seat belts for several minutes, does anyone know the facts? And, do you think more drills in a school year would benefit the children and help insure safer and more efficient drills? Can we ever keep them too safe?
Kathy Weidman, Bus Operator
West Virginia

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by patrick carnicella at 8/8/2007 8:43 AM
As a transportation director I want to say thank you to the bus driver for doing a great job. To the parents of the children thank god this is all that happened from the accident.
We always say we carry the future and in this case the future is bright. These are all special people that went through an experience that they must realize the plan for the future.
We all have problems but with miracles like this look and say how bad is it really?

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Charlie Hood at 8/8/2007 9:56 AM
So much has been done with emergency evacuation since Carrolton, Kentucky and Alton, Texas in the late 1980s, but this event reminded us we can never let our guard down. We now have lots of exits in buses, we do drills with our passengers, NHTSA is finalizing its new inservice training module for drivers on evacuation, we in Florida require an FAA style evacuation script before each field and activity trip, and on and on.

In real life, though, fires, drownings, and other threats inside the bus could strike at any time. Drivers and all of us must believe in the importance of our equipment specs, our training, and our drills. To this day, I am still amazed by how often I see coolers in the aisles of buses. We must practice what we preach and take these things seriously. Then maybe preparation plus providence will continue to serve our children well.

# re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Charlotte Grabowski at 8/9/2007 5:12 AM
I think that the fact that this was a charter trip is important. Were these kids regular school bus riders? I like Mr Hood's suggestion of an evacuation script to be read prior to each trip. I do go over rules and exit information prior to each charter trip but a scripted talk would insure that nothing got left out. We can not drill too often with our regular riders; any time spent parked at school can be used to talk about safety. We need to do more to educate those that only ride occasionally and the community at large who may be called on to help us.

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Shirley Reeves at 8/9/2007 6:46 AM

Thank God for the safety of these students and those that cared enough to help to get the students off the bus. We are still a caring nation that stand together in times of trouble and needs. It is so importation that all school personal alond with the drivers and coaches who drive knows the evacuation drill of school buses. Not all students ride a school bus to school but do ride on fields and athletic trips, it is just importation they know the evacuation drill.I am very proud to be part of the transportation of school students. Anyone can drive a car but it takes someone special to drive a school bus. School bus drivers do carry the future my hat off to all school bus drivers and the wonderful job they do as a driver. God bless and always watch over these special people who care enough to take on this responsibility to drive a school bus.

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Diane Jackson at 8/10/2007 6:01 PM
I would like to see more information about the woman who was driving the bus! She is a true hero. As a driver myself I understand the importance of remaining calm in all situations involving the bus, but I cannot in my wildest dreams or should I say nightmares imagine what that was like. Please someone at First Student make sure that woman gets roses often for the remainder of her life! If your out there and happen to read this,know that you are very much a hero to me and I thank you from the bottom of my heart!

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by EH Roberson at 8/11/2007 9:38 AM
As bad as this incident was, I must ask the question "What would have been the out come if the 60' odd students been seat belted, " from the news report, many children were confused, panic, very terrified, been they seat belted, more time required to evaluate and possible trapped chldren if seat belts jamed, need some type of cutter to release the kids, now I am not saying school buses sould not have seat belts, but this situation needs to really factor into the arguement concerning seat belt on school buses

 re: The school bus and the bridge

left by Beverly at 8/12/2007 1:08 PM
As a bus driver , i wonder what the capacity of this bus was? Should 60 + students/adults have been on the same vehicle. I commend the rescuers and am glad no one was seriously injured or killed, but I also wonder about why that many people were in this one vehicle.

Add A Comment

Title   
Name 
Email (never displayed) 
Url 
Comments   
Please add 7 and 7 and type the answer here: