Don’t fall out of your seat

When I was in elementary school, my aunt would often pick me and my siblings up at the end of the day.

Along with our occasional trips to Carl’s Jr. for an after-school treat, something that stands out in my memory about those days is that we kids would often have to remind our aunt to put on her seat belt before she began driving.

Whether she just tended to forget to buckle up or she tried to avoid it because the belt was uncomfortable, I’m not sure. But in retrospect, those seat belt situations seem to illustrate a difference between generations.

My siblings and I were raised with the importance of seat belt use so ingrained in us that not buckling up in a car was unthinkable. On the other hand, my aunt grew up riding in cars that didn’t even have seat belts.

I never questioned my aunt’s concern for safety. In fact, she was just as protective of me and my siblings as our parents were, and she is one of the most selfless and caring people I know. But I’m glad we were there to make sure she wore her seat belt.

So here’s the pertinent question: Do some school bus drivers need their passengers (or someone else) to remind them to buckle up?

One of the more startling news stories I find on occasion is that of an unbelted school bus driver who fell out of his or her seat. In some cases, the ejection occurs after the bus becomes involved in a crash, but sometimes the crash is a result of the driver falling out of the seat, maybe while turning or hitting a bump.

In June 2011, a school bus driver in Holt, Mich., crashed her bus into a garage. Police said that the driver was not belted and had fallen from her seat into the entrance well of the bus while making a left turn. There were no kids on the bus, and the driver only suffered minor injuries, but she was ticketed and then elected to retire from her position.

More recently, in December of last year, a 67-year-old school bus driver in Natchitoches Parish, La., was killed when she lost control of her bus, exited the highway and struck trees and a fence before traveling down an embankment. Although police said it was suspected that a medical condition was the primary cause of the crash, they pointed out that the driver was not wearing her seat belt.

Also last year, after an unbelted school bus driver in Carmel, Ind., was bounced out of his seat and crashed, a news team from WISH-TV shot footage in four school districts and found multiple bus drivers either wearing their seat belts improperly or not wearing them at all.

These incidents should serve as cautionary tales to any school bus drivers who haven’t made it a priority to properly wear their seat belts. The incidents also show the need for managers to regularly monitor their drivers’ seat belt use — and to enforce penalties for not complying.

Don’t leave it to the kids to make sure their drivers are buckling up.

— Thomas McMahon, executive editor

Print | posted on Monday, February 11, 2013 1:33 PM

Comments

# re: Don’t fall out of your seat

left by Lori Riddles at 2/11/2013 2:36 PM
I remember my family members not buckling, but I think most school bus drivers do buckle up. It would be awfully embarrassing to be that one school bus driver who fell out of the seat. Even worse if it was on video. Wow, cautionary is right! Thanks Tom for the interesting post.

 re: Don’t fall out of your seat

left by Derek Graham at 2/12/2013 4:47 AM
After the Huntsville crash, several North Carolina school districts began a pilot program featuring a "bumper sticker" posted INSIDE the bus. It quotes the law and reminds everyone that the driver is required to wear a seat belt and is prohibited from using a cell phone. It features a "hotline" phone number that rings at the NC Department of Public Instruction. We get occasional calls from students and forward the information to the transportation director - but not as many as in past years. I think these posted reminders are helping the cause.

 re: Don’t fall out of your seat

left by Charlie Hood at 2/12/2013 7:03 AM
I'll start my comment with a disclaimer. This is a huge pet peeve of mine. Not because the vast majority of professional school bus drivers don't wear their belts (they do), but because those few who don't can do so much damage to themselves, their students, and their employers in human misery, dollars, and/or simply public perception. You've illustrated that very well with your examples (especially Huntsville, where the NTSB stopped just short of saying the cause of the bus going over the guardrail was because the driver fell out of his seat). And maybe it IS generational, but I'm nearly 60 and have worn a belt every time, every trip, since 1963 when lap belts first began to appear in cars.

Derek and others are doing the right thing; there is no substitute for seat belt compliance being a priority of management. Most drivers will do the right thing and wear their belts properly without enforcement, but for those few who won't, they need to know there are employment consequences that don't allow them to wait for the ultimate consequence of a serious injury or fatality to themselves or others.

NHTSA released a very interesting study a couple years ago that validated the effectiveness of seat belt/transmission interlocks for drivers in commercial vehicles. As a former technician, I'm not a huge advocate of more bells and whistles on our buses, but devices that prevent the driver from putting the vehicle in gear when not buckled up proved very effective. Just food for thought, and possible discussion at the next National Congress on School Transportation.

 re: Don’t fall out of your seat

left by Cheryl Jordan at 2/12/2013 10:21 AM
When I am in my car I have to be reminded by my grandchildren to buckle up but on the bus I never forget. I need all the help I can get to stay in that seat. You bounce like you are at a circus ride when you hit bad road.

# re: Don’t fall out of your seat

left by jkraemer at 2/12/2013 10:39 PM
The first car that I rode in that had seat belts was a 1950's foreign sports car my school councilor owned. He saw me walking, figured I missed the bus, and gave me a ride to school. He insisted I buckle, strange device but did so. He rounded a sharp 15mph corner at 30mph or so, showing off I guess. My door flew open, the door, and my head within inches of a car in the other lane, and my head a few inches off the ground. Seems the device saved my life, although I didn't give that any actual consideration back then. Near two decades studying this issue concerning the school buses, I've come to the same conclusion for the buses - Belts can save lives, lots of lives. Not only ought children remind their bus driver to buckle-up, but school buses ought to be equipped with seat belts and the bus driver returning the favor.

 re: Don’t fall out of your seat

left by Henry at 2/13/2013 10:31 AM
Here's a good one.......we have a driver who refuses to wear her seat belt properly. She does wear the lap portion but puts the shoulder belt behind her. In order to get around "properly" wearing her belt she produced a note from her doctor. It is state law that safety belts are to be worn the right way. I'm wondering does the doctor have authority over the law? Sure seems a bit strange to me.

# re: Don’t fall out of your seat

left by jkraemer at 2/14/2013 10:32 AM
"Does the doctor have authority over the [seat belt] law?" ANSR: In most states I believe yes they do. People can also sit in the pick-up bed not belted if there is no seating available to use in the cab. Most states allow a toddler in an infant car seat placed in the front seat. Check police, your state laws, or with a lawyer to find out if these things apply in your state.

 re: Don’t fall out of your seat

left by nutch at 2/15/2013 11:10 AM
My grandpa usually buckles up in his car and always buckles up in his bus. he is always complaining that he is the only one that has to buckle up in it!

Add A Comment

Title   
Name 
Email (never displayed) 
Url 
Comments   
Please add 3 and 1 and type the answer here: